History of Nursing Essay

Over time there control been numerous books about the decimal point of relevance that care for is devoten as a transaction and as a remains of science. This paper shall seek to vex a comparative discussion on ii books that are of prominence in this regard. The low gear is discussion the dour the women of St. Lukes and the personality of treat, 1892-1937 by Tom Craig Olson and Eileen Walsh, period the assist is enjoin to business the quandary of Ameri usher out care for, 1850-1945 by Susan Reverby. The following paragraphs shall attempt to highlighting the key areas of this book and shall attempt to present a contrast between the perspectives that they present.Susan Reverby states actually clearly in the first hardly a(prenominal) pages of her book I will palisade that breast feeding is a form of get the picture shaped by the obligation to care. simply its biography, and ultimately its identity sensnot be soundless unless the bond that has wedded it to wo manhood is excessively unraveled and revealed (Reverby, 1987, p. 1) It is evident from this excerpt that the focus of Susan Reverbys book Ordered to Care is not care for itself, merely treat as a commerce that is generally trustworthy to women.She does not present details that could be attri unlessed to her perspective of nursing as a profession that can be regarded as equal for both genders that conducts to greet nursing as it evolved for the woman of the hunting lodge and how the womans ability to care became an integral part of modern solar day nursing. In Ordered to Care, Susan Reverby frequently mentions diachronic events in the history of nursing that served to miscellany the way that nursing is perceived today. She does so in order to present propositions and claims in retrospect and seeks to issue the skimer with a cause-and-effect based relationship between the events that she brings up.Susan Reverby is of the judgement that nursing underwent a steady paced sue through with(predicate) which it was eventually feminized. She mentions nursing r ontogenyists much(prenominal) as Elizabeth Christopher Hobson and also mentions pioneers in the line of business of nursing such as the kinds of Florence nightingale. Susan Reverby gives excess regard to the nursing as a womans profession in her book and highlights the areas and events that led to the bustment of nursing to a point where it can flat be considered to be a profession that is free of any form of invalidating sexuality that could be expected to give room to eroticism as was the causal agent in 1872.A Georgia Sturtevant may confine been impressed by infirmary order and the gentleness of the nurses, but kindliness reformer Elizabeth Christopher Hobson was overwhelmed in 1872 by the horrific dirt, foul smells and disorder she encountered when touring New Yorks Bellevue Hospital (Reverby, 1987, p. 39) It is however, essential to highlight that through discussions such as the author Susan Reverby is by no means attempting to present a chronological elaboration of nursing but is in fact seeking to develop the bigger picture through which a reader can see on the dot how nursing has become the complex profession it is perceived as today.When one was to read Tom Craig Olson and Eileen Walshs Handling the sick the women of St. Lukes and the nature of nursing, 1892-1937, it is evident that the authors were skillful as inspired by untested and pioneering figures in the history of nursing as was Susan Reverby in Ordered to care the dilemma of American nursing. The presence of this relationship can be surmised through the fact that while Susan Reverby chooses to elaborate on the precise implications that Florence Nightingale had on nursing, Tom Craig Olson and Eileen Walsh choose to acquire their book with her quotation. In the book Handling the sick the women of St.Lukes and the nature of nursing, 1892-1937 by Tom Craig Olson and Eileen Walsh, the authors choose to focus on the outgrowth of nursing as a profession with regard to the general remote factors that had an implication on nursing when nursing from the late 1890s to the late 1930s. The authors bear an discussion on the evolution of nursing during this time period in mien in which they choose to discuss aspects such as technology and the desire amongst nursing professionals to associate nursing with aspects that pertained to care and doctor for patients rather than with aspects that pertained to technological advancements.Also, while Susan Reverby chooses to residuum her discussion on nursing upon the evolution of nursing with respect to the function and wisdom of women in the field of nursing, Tom Craig Olson and Eileen Walsh choose to rest their discussion on not but the events and incidents that served an integral purpose in the dictation of the history of nursing but also address how research on nursing during the years of 1892 and 1937 contributed to the develop ment of the nursing profession and the evolution of its perception in society. A major work on Nebraska nursing education, for instance, concludes that little grade evidence exists about early discipline programs because, in general, programs did not keep records. In place of such evidence, the study is representative of other in its dependence on accreditation material from the state board of nursing, on with legislative documents, to infer what apprenticeship in nursing was like (Olson & Walsh, 2004, p. 4).Tom Craig Olson and Eileen Walsh are of the feel that the degree to which professionalism has dominated nursing and the degree to which historians spend a penny chosen to give revere to professionalism in their portrayal of nursing history play highly significant roles in the history of nursing. It is also evident that the authors have chosen to present nursing as a field which is influenced significantly as a result of new developments.These new developments may not nece ssarily have to be associated with the constituent elements of nursing but can also be set to exist in the form of the development of the perception of nursing in society. It can therefore be surmised that while Ordered to care the dilemma of American nursing, 1850-1945 by Susan Reverby is a highly credible and instructive book, the author appears to have given a high degree of regard to the role of women in the evolution of American nursing.On the other hand, Handling the sick the women of St. Lukes and the nature of nursing, 1892-1937 by Tom Craig Olson and Eileen Walsh appears to provide a more broader picture towards nursing and its evolution by discussing not only the contribution of pioneering figures and revolutionary events in nursing but by also providing an brainwave into the evolution of the nursing profession in general.